Fantasia 2009

The Clone Returns Home (Kanji Nakajima, 2008)

WHAT IT IS: After his accidental death during a mission in outer space, Kohei Takahara, an astronaut, is cloned in order to continue the mission. But the clone, fixating on a traumatic childhood memory of the original Kohei, goes AWOL and attempts to return to “his” childhood home.

HOW IT IS: Although the premise seems ripe for the movie becoming a welcome addition to the minimalist cerebral sci-fi genre, and it was produced by notable German filmmaker Wim Wenders known for thought-provoking films like the poetic Wings of Desire (1987) and the road-movie Paris, Texas (1984), The Clone Returns Home disappoints.

The Clone Returns Home is a two-hour light philosophical attempt at existentialist angst, mostly imitating the best directors of the genre (like Kubrick or Tarkovsky) instead of bringing its own ideas and its own perspective to the mix, never trying hard or reaching far enough, failing to live up to the legacy of classic sci-fi films, barely scratching the surface of the ethical minefield of human cloning.

Although visually stunning, The Clone Returns Home is tedious, long-winded and monotonous. Littered with missed opportunities, the movie fades from memory as soon as the credits start rolling.

IF YOU LIKE: Minimalist cerebral sci-fi like Gattaca, 1984, A Clockwork Orange, and Moon.

More info on IMDB

Eric Lafalaise

Eric Lafalaise mostly communicates by writing and telling stories. He is a contributing writer to the Kinoreal film blog, a producer for Red Brand Studios, an artist, a photographer, a tech freak, and an all-around (left-right) brain nut.

Recent Posts

Black Panther: A Perspective

I haven’t been motivated enough by any of the recent movies to add to the…

6 years ago

On the dopeness of Black Panther

I’ve been excited about Black Panther from the moment I heard about it. Anything that…

6 years ago

Spectre (Sam Mendes, 2015)

After the tragic death of M and to honour her memory, James Bond uncovers a…

8 years ago

Seven Pounds (Gabriele Muccino, 2008)

Seven Pounds is a great concept but executed with poor vision. The supporting cast is…

9 years ago

Honeymoon (Leigh Janiak, 2014)

Honeymoon is like the edge of a blade, which could turn out quite dull or…

9 years ago

Live (Noboru Iguchi, 2014)

What is most impressive with Live is its infectious energy.Every death, every plot point is…

9 years ago